Gift a subscription
You can purchase any plan for someone else, and choose how long to purchase the subscription for.
Join the NEW Fan Cult!
The Fan Cult is taking new members!
We’ve got new offerings, new levels, and all the ad-free audio and video content your creepy little heart desires. Whether you’re a long-time Fan Cult member or thinking about joining the fold, there’s a tier for you.
The Fan Cult got an upgrade!
0:00
0:00
00:33
Listen on:
$5
USD
/ month
$5
USD
$4.17
USD
/ month
(billed annually)
Everything you’ve loved about the original Fan Cult—now with more access, more content and a little more cult energy.
Your membership includes:
Your membership includes:
- Weekly bonus audio every Tuesday: Two extra hometowns straight from Karen and Georgia, only for Fan Cult ears.
- Weekly bonus video every Friday: This exclusive content features unfiltered, behind-the-scenes conversations, audience interaction, games and more!
- Access to the new Fan Cult Discord: This is a members-only digital commune where you can chat, debate, spiral and bond with other Murderinos.
- Early access to live show tickets when they return: No ritual sacrifices required. Just a solid Wi-Fi connection and that Murderino loyalty.
See you on the inside!
$10
USD
/ month
$10
USD
$8.33
USD
/ month
(billed annually)
You get everything from You’re In A Cult, plus a few premium perks.
Your membership includes:
Your membership includes:
-
Ad-free access to all My Favorite Murder audio content:
- No interruptions, no ads—all Karen. All Georgia. You’ll get ad-free versions of Monday Minisodes, Wednesday episodes of Rewind with Karen & Georgia and Thursday main episodes. All delivered straight to your favorite podcast platform.
- Ad-free long-form video: Watch all the My Favorite Murder video content you love—without commercials. That includes full Thursday episodes. No sales pitches, just uninterrupted true crime.
- A $20 merch store credit: Matching merch for you and your coven. (Codes are sent out annually; check your inbox for a separate email with your code).
Treat yourself to the peaceful joy of uninterrupted content.
Payment methods:
Credit Card
Credit Card
about
My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
Since My Favorite Murder launched in January of 2016, Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark have shared their lifelong interest in true crime stories and have covered infamous serial killers, mysterious cold cases, captivating cults, incredible survivor stories and important events from history.
www.myfavoritemurder.com
www.myfavoritemurder.com
Frequently Asked Questions
Ready to get started?
Subscribe Now
How do I listen to subscriber-exclusive podcasts and content?
We will provide you with a unique podcast feed that you'll be able to
add to your favorite podcast player. Adding this feed to your favorite
podcast player only takes a couple of taps. We currently support
Apple Podcasts, Youtube Music, Spotify, Castro, Downcast, Overcast, Pocket Casts, Podcast Addict, Podcast Republic, Podkicker, Rss Radio, and more.
How do I get in touch?
For technical support, e-mail support@supercast.com
For show questions, e-mail fancult@myfavoritemurder.com.
What is Supercast?
Supercast is a platform that makes it easy for podcasters like
My Favorite Murder - Fan Cult Exclusives to create a premium membership for their fans.
Find out more.
Can I send a subscription as a gift?
Yes! Just click on 'Gift a Subscription'
at the top of this page. You can choose how long your gift subscription applies for.
Your credit card won't be associated with the subscription, and to continue after the
gift period, the subscriber will need to provide payment info.
How do I cancel my subscription?
You can cancel your subscription at any time from your subscription page. Once you cancel,
you'll continue to receive premium benefits for the remainder of your payment period.
© 2025 Supercast